Laura Reyes
Prof. Joellen Hiltbrand
Engl-205, Sec. 8437
13 April 2019
Project
3: Chinese Culture
There
are many cultures around the world as well as here in America. People have
different spiritual beliefs. Some people believe in Buddha while others believe
in Jesus Christ. Some cultures see big ear lobes as good luck and other
cultures see big ear lobes as being unattractive. Some cultures valued females
having small feet. Some cultures do not eat beef and others do not eat pork. In
some cultures drinking alcohol is looked down upon. Some cultures require women
to be covered up while other cultures let the individual women decide what they
want to wear. Moving along, the book I chose to read was The Joy Luck Club, by Amy Tan. This book was about four mothers and
their four daughters, who lived in San Francisco, CA. They grew up differently,
since the daughters grew up in America. In reading The Joy Luck Club I have learned a lot of things of the Chinese
culture and its beliefs and I will discuss these things in my paper.
The
belief of the elements in each individual affect the way each individual’s
character. Jing-Mei Woo’s mom taught her daughter about these elements. She
said that each person is made of five elements. “Too much fire and you had a
bad temper. That was like my father, whom my mother always criticized for his
cigarette habit and who always shouted back that she should keep her thoughts
to herself” (Tan, 31). “Too little wood and you bent too quickly to listen to
other people’s ideas, unable to stand on your own” (Tan, 31). Too much water
made you flow in many directions. “…Like myself, for having started a degree in
biology, then half a degree in art, and then finishing neither when I went off
work for a small ad agency as a secretary, later becoming a copywriter (Tan,
31).
They
believe in a type of superstition to bring luck. When Rose Hsu Jordan was a
young girl, she lost her youngest brother at the Ocean. Her mom believed that
the reason her youngest son, Bing fell into the ocean was because of what one
of her ancestors did. Rose’s mother, An-mei Hsu said the following to Rose. “’An
ancestor of ours once stole water from a sacred well. Now the water is trying
to steal back. We must sweeten the temper of the Coiling Dragon who lives in the
sea. And then we must make him loosen his coils from Bing by giving him another
treasure he can hide’” (Tan, 129).
An-mei believed she can bring Bing back safe and sound. “My mother
poured out tea sweetened with sugar into the teacup, and threw it into the sea.
And then she opened her fist. In her palm was a ring of watery blue sapphire, a
gift from her mother, who had died many years before. This ring, she told me,
drew coveting stares from women and made them inattentive to the children they
guarded so jealously. This would make the Coiling Dragon forgetful of Bing. She
threw the ring into the water” (Tan, 129). Unfortunately, she was not able to
bring Bing back. I was hoping that he would appear, but they never even found
his body.
They
believe that a missing leg will bring bad luck on Chinese New Year. “I poked
the crabs with a pencil to see how feisty they were. If a crab grabbed on, I
lifted it out and into a plastic sack. I lifted one crab this way, only to find
one of its legs had been clamped onto by another crab. In the brief tug-of-war,
my crab lost a limb” (Tan, 200). This was when Jing-Mei Woo was a kid and
helping her mother, Suyuan Woo do the shopping for Chinese New Year. “’Put it
back,’” whispered my mother. “’A missing leg is a bad sign on Chinese New Year’”
(Tan, 200).
They
believe in Chinese astrology. “I was born in the year of the Tiger. It was a
very bad year to be born, a very good year to be a Tiger” (Tan, 248). Ying-Ying
St. Clair, one of the mothers was sharing this with her daughter, Lena St.
Clair. “Then she told me why a tiger is gold and black. It has two ways. The
gold side leaps with its fierce heart. The black side stands still with
cunning, hiding its gold between trees, seeing and not being seen, waiting
patiently for things to come. I did not learn to use my black side until after
the bad man left me” (Tan, 248). The Chinese astrology has 12 signs like
western astrology, only that it is changes yearly.
They
believe that certain face characteristics mean something. Lindo Jong, read her
daughter face, Wavery Jong. “’You are lucky,’” she said. “’You have my ears, a
big thick lobe, lots of meat at the bottom, full of blessings. Some people are
born so poor. Their ears are so thin, so close to their head, they can’t ever
hear luck calling to them…You have my nose. The hole is not too big, so your
money will not be running out. The nose is straight and smooth, a good sign. A
girl with a cricked nose is bound for misfortune…’”She tapped my chin and then
hers. ”’Not too short, not too long. Our longevity will be adequate, not cut
off too soon, not so long we become a burden.’” She pushed my hair away from my
forehead…”’Perhaps your forehead is wider, so you will be even more clever. And
your hair is thick, the hairline is low on your forehead. This means you will
have some hardships early in life’” (Tan, 256-257). This part was very
interesting to me that every detail of our face means something.
In
conclusion, I have learned a lot about the Chinese culture and its beliefs.
This is what amazes me about the Chinese culture. It is very complex and full
of mystery and fortunes. It is very unique compared to modern western culture
and that is what makes it interesting to me. I really enjoyed reading The Joy Luck Club.
Work
Cited
Tan, Amy. The Joy Luck Club. Penguin Books,
2014, pp. 17-288.
HI, Laura, nice job on your analysis and a thesis statement you have done a great job on setting the stage for the reader and informing them what it is you are going to be writing about. You have also done a great job throughout the body paragraph picking out some great quotes and then basing you writing off of that, nice job.
ReplyDeleteHi Laura!
ReplyDeleteI read The Joy Luck Club for my novel too. I agree this was a great book and I really enjoyed it. I love how you pulled out all of these Chinese beliefs from the novel. I really enjoyed the direction you wrote your paper. You have strong quotes from the novel and explained them very well. It is interesting how superstitious the Chinese are, everything has a meaning, even the simplest of things like the crab having a broken or bad leg, to me I would think that it would be ok to eat but they think it’s bad luck. It is sad to me that we are losing these cultural beliefs because the longer a family stays away from their native country, the more they become more like the culture they live in. Great job on this project. I really enjoyed reading it.
Hi Grace!
ReplyDeleteGreat job on comparing two completely different stories. I really enjoyed the way you compared the two. It is a great example of how one story can be analyzed many different ways. I think the quotes you have chosen are great, I personally like a lot of quotes, I believe they give a lot of supporting information for the reader. I would like another quote or two in the first few chapters. It is very sad that Vietnamese woman are taught to see themselves in such a negative way, everyone should see their own beauty. Great job.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi, Laura!
ReplyDeleteI really liked that you made a few comparisons between the many kinds of cultural beliefs. I found it so interesting seeing how all around the world things work differently. Also, I saw that there is a movie based on this book. Have you watched it? It seems nice, I even thought of watching it.
Talking about the actual project now: I found your transitions between those comparisons and the title of the book you've chosen too abrupt. I would suggest you write a slight transition when changing the topics. Also, your thesis statement is not much clear. You said you would discuss beliefs in the project, but you put too many quotes and barely explained them. The 5th paragraph, for example, you said "They believe in Chinese astrology" and the rest of the paragraph was quotes without any explanation or analysis.
When I was taking English 100 I was taught that when putting quotes, we have to introduce it, add the quote and then explain it one by one. The reader should not wonder why the quotes are there.
I hope you will find it helpful somehow.
Hello Laura,
ReplyDeleteYour project 3 submission came out very good. It was interesting to read your thoughts and personal opinions towards some things as you compared it to what you have read in your story. The quotes and proof that you have provided from your reading made it easy to follow and understand what you were trying to get across. However, I am not sure what your thesis statement is so you may want to refresh that. Overall, good job
Hi Laura,
ReplyDeleteThis was my favorite project to read so far! Not only was it very well written, but I truly learned something from reading. I have always known Chinese had many superstitions, but you not only listed many out but you provided perfect quotes from the text that supported each of your claims. As many folks above me have mentioned, while the content of your project is excellent, you do not fully address or conclude your thesis statement within the project. Even so, I still really enjoyed reading your project and am now intrigued to read the story myself!
Thank you for sharing! Great job.